Posts by Alexandra Ruffell
July 25, 2015

Albert Park: 386 Ferrars St, (Cayzer), after auction, $1.72m, 3 bidders
With only a small number of $1m+ auction numbers this weekend, the results didn’t tell us too much. Unless we see either a big increase in stock levels, or a sudden drop in the number of buyers looking to purchase, the next few months are likely to be more of the same.
The current feeling is that stock levels will not satisfy buyer demand, and this will keep the market healthy. Mainland Chinese interest also remains strong for the ‘right’ properties, and this is having a big effect in the inner Melbourne market prices.
We have seen a trend this year in the increased demand for properties on smaller land. Buyers appear to be more willing to compromise on their garden size to be closer to shops, stations and schools.
We believe this has been brought about by a number of factors:
- The need to be close to transport and shops
- Budget limits, where increased ‘$ square metre’ rates are pushing properties on larger land into less affordable price brackets for many buyers
- A tech driven generation who spend more time indoors
- Limited options for the downsizer market
- Lack of stock in general
- Council zoning changes
Two key sales this weekend:
- 4 Flowerdale Road Glen Iris (Anthony Smith, Woodards), undisclosed, circa $2m. A dated 80s home, approximately 715sqm, in the ‘Hill and Dale’ area.
- 4 Orlando Street Hampton (Amanda Jones, Hodges), 434sqm, $1.505m or almost $3,500sqm.
Not everything sold on Saturday:
- 17 Victoria Grove Hawthorn East (Greg Toogood, Jellis Craig), passed in VB $1.7m. Pretty double fronted timber Edwardian with a functional single level floor plan, but no off street parking. Now a private sale asking $1.95m.
Off-market talk continues, and it appears to us that if you a buyer over $2m then there could be a lot more choices off-market or privately than just those advertised on the internet.
- Stately Italianate Victorian in Hawthorn – $3.5m
- Well positioned, lock-and-leave smaller home over two levels in Domain area South Yarra, early $2ms
- Large period home in Kew, west of the junction – $2.8m
- Comfortable double-storey brick home, Glen Iris near Corowa School – $2.5m
- Modern family home, good street, Brighton $4m+
- New single storey home, Beaumaris circa $3m
- Options for Bayside family homes with pools and courts, $6m+
Architecturally Speaking
What makes a good townhouse?

1 Trafalgar Mont Albert
We get this question a lot, and when you walk a good townhouse, you just know they are going to be well received by the market. 1 Trafalgar Street Mont Albert (listed by Stuart Evans, Marshall White), is testament to this. Of course nothing is ever perfect (some may not like the style of this home, and think it lacks a deeper, consolidated courtyard area), yet here are ten quick points that make this a great property:
- Great garaging – wide enough for two cars to park side-by side and direct access into the house;
- Ground floor master bedroom suite – no steps to negotiate for day-to day living;
- North facing rear – great for natural light and passive solar gain into informal living areas and rear yard;
- Good bedroom separation, secondary bedrooms upstairs which are of good size;
- Quality fit out (albeit a bit dated). Most buyers are very discerning with ‘cheap’ builds;
- Tall ceiling heights – great for spatial feel and air-flow;
- Low maintenance external finishes;
- Good storage options;
- Generous room sizes;
- External access from laundry.

Unsurprisingly renowned local architect Michael Monkton designed this, and 14 years on it still works, and works very well. Many people struggle with the cost of a good architect, but it really can be money very well spent which comes back to you in spades when it comes time to sell.
Auction Snapshot:

Malvern East: 101 Manning Rd (Jellis Craig), under hammer, $2.16m, 5 bidders
101 Manning Road, Malvern East (Adam Cashmere, Jellis Craig), under hammer, $2.16m, 5 bidders
Well over 100 people turn up for the auction of this brick Edwardian home, which boasts 707m2 of north facing rear land, yet it is located on a T-intersection and lacks covered car-parking or potential for it. Auctioneer John Morrisby offers a warm welcome (which is appreciated, given the stiff winter chill) and gives a spirited preamble, and listing agent Adam Cashmore is ready to take down the bids. John duly opens the auction up at with a vendor bid of $1.7m, which is a good move just to kick things along, and not long after a bidder in the crowd cordially obliges with a $25K rise. Not long after bidders 2 and 3 join in and the auction clips along nicely. The property is announced on the market at $2.030m, and then it starts to pull up at the $2.1m mark, selling under the hammer for $2,160,000. 5 bidders in all here fought things out, and the result was not a ‘flyer’ but ‘about right’.

Malvern East: 36 Ferncroft Ave (Jellis Craig), passed in, $3m, 3 bidders
36 Ferncroft Ave, Malvern East (John Morrisby, Jellis Craig), passed in, $3m, 3 bidders
A crowd of around 75 gathered to see what would occur at the auction of this huge piece of Malvern East land, on a corner near Hedgeley Dene gardens – approximately 1263sqm selling with plans and permits for three dwellings. John Morrisby was our auctioneer and the spectators, including one or two developers/investors, huddled around him as he began proceedings. A low opening of $2m came from the crowd. John thanked the bidder for his offer, but quickly tabled a vendor bid of $2.5m in response. Bidder 2 offered $2.6m before John headed inside for a quick referral. Back outside, John tabled a second vendor bid of $2.8m before Bidder 2 offered $2.85m. Bidder 3 entered the competition with a $25k rise and after a couple more bids, the property was passed in to Bidder 3 at $3m.
Agent Opinion: How are stock levels looking as we head into Spring?
Damian O’Sullivan (Marshall White): “Stock levels in the wake of school holidays appear to be very healthy and should go some way to appease the strong demand we’ve seen in recent months. With 5 Saturdays in August, volume will naturally be higher than average and will assist many owners wanting to take advantage of vendor-biased conditions.”

Andrew Campbell (Buxton): “After the school holiday period, buyer numbers at opens are still positive. Also, stock levels might still be a bit lean but we will see more properties hitting the market in coming weeks for a very big August.”
John Morrisby (Jellis Craig): “August will be well supported by way of stock levels, especially by the more inner areas. September and October are starting to take shape with the ‘school belt’ locales beginning to help make spring selling decisions. All in all, numbers are solid to good but not overwhelming.”
July 18, 2015

Albert Park: 100 Kerferd Rd (Marshall White), passed in, $2.85m
Winter in Melbourne. Traditionally not a great time for selling property as gardens are dormant and many people are focused on other activities such as school holidays, overseas adventures and the football.
In terms of new trends, we are seeing a growing section of the market (in particular the family home buyer) moving away from larger blocks of land in favour of functional, well-designed homes in close proximity to the shops and transport. As a result, we are starting to see big variances in the suburb dollar/sqm rates depending on the land size, orientation and location. For example, 1 Mildura Avenue, Sandringham (which has been bought as a new build site) recently sold for over $3,000 sqm, a figure more commonly seen in Brighton. More than ever, if you are a buyer in this market having a greater understanding of where the market ‘sees’ the value of the property will be all–important.
While there has been plenty of talk in the media about the market pulling back over recent weeks, we and many others think the market is still travelling strongly. Traditional supply and demand market indicators are still suggesting that the demand to buy is greater than the stock levels available to choose from.
Whilst auction numbers are down, predominantly as a result of the holiday period, there have still been some strong results.
- 9 Malua Street Ormond (Aviv Samuel, Gary Peer) 5/7/15, $2.6185m. A landmark home, this was a large Victorian needing update work on approx. 1315sqm land, with two street frontages.
- 6 Grange Road Kew (Tim Picken, Kay & Burton), 3/7/15 (Friday evening auction), $3.82m. Opening at $3.3m, most acknowledged the house was ordinary, the real value was in the approx. 860sqm of land (which was free of easements and overlays), selling for $4,441sqm.
As the holidays draw to an end, a number of campaigns commencing Saturday were well attended.
- 1 Trafalgar Street Mont Albert (Stuart Evans/Duane Wolowiec Marshall White) About 40 groups through for this Michael Monkton townhouse, which cleverly has it’s main bedroom on the ground floor (i.e. no steps for downsizes to contend with)
- 9 Bamfield Street Sandringham (Danny Corcoran/Sam Harrison, Buxton) had close to 80 people through. Keys pluses here are the position, north facing land and a liveable Fasham Johnson house likely to suit a wide buyer group, and even on the smaller land. With 1 Mildura (mentioned earlier) selling as land just around the corner for $1,405,000, the additional flexibility that this property offers will attract a larger buyer group and competition, which may result in an even stronger result.
A number of ‘off-market’ homes have also continued to present throughout the holiday period:
- Iconic local home in Mont Albert – c$3.5m
- Dated original home with pleasant parkland outlook in Camberwell – $1.8m
- Single level 3 bedroom original home in Brighton – c$2.5m
- Large single level renovated home in Hawthorn East – early $3m’s
With the Spring market now approaching, buyers are anticipating good levels of new property coming on to the market. August 8th is shaping up to be the first big auction weekend, post holidays. With the ‘double 8’ date, competition could be strong as buyers (particularly Chinese) bid to purchase on this ‘lucky’ date.
Auction Highlights:

Hampton: 10 Lagnicourt St, (Rowan Thompson, RT Edgar), under hammer, $1.685m, 4 bidders
10 Lagnicourt St, Hampton (Rowan Thompson, RT Edgar), under hammer, $1.685m, 4 bidders
A sunny midday auction in the front yard of this Californian bungalow in the sought after Castlefield Estate. The crowd of around 70 clambered for a spot in the sun as auctioneer Rowan Thompson stood on the front veranda and went through the preliminaries. A vendor bid of $1.4m opened proceedings, before Bidder 1 joined in at $1.42m. Bidder 2 offered a $20k rise and after a quick succession of bids, the home was announced on the market at $1.52m. Bidders 3 and 4 entered the competition and the bids crept up slowly until the hammer came down to a very happy Bidder 4 at $1.685m.

South Yarra: 6.1/193 Domain Rd (Anthony Reis, Marshall White), bought after auction
6.1/193 Domain Rd, South Yarra (Anthony Reis, Marshall White), after auction, undisclosed above $1.525m
A brisk clear winter day greeted myself and about 100 others for the auction of this landmark ‘untouched’ South Yarra apartment on Domain Road, designed by renowned local architect Robin Boyd. Back in May this building featured as part of Melbourne’s “Exemplary Apartments” open day and rightly so. Here interiors are arranged with small-windowed service rooms on the south, while living areas and bedrooms take great advantage of sweeping views and light to the north with curtain walls of floor to ceiling glass and random balconies. “Domain Park’ is a local icon, these apartments do come up every so often, and whenever they do there is always good interest. Yet the company share title structuring, low ceilings and often dated internal fit-outs do deter many buyers, so the ‘interest’ is mainly from locals or diehard Boyd fans (like me). Auctioneer Marcus Chimenello and listing agent Anthony Reis conducted the auction in the park across the road – which was a great setting (and a very logical one). Marcus gave a good intro, then looked for bids. After it was clear there were none forthcoming, a vendor bid of $1.5m was placed. This did little to excite the crowd, and the vendor was referred to (luckily they were standing in the park and not back in the apartment!) and after a few minutes the auction resumed. Eventually, a crowd bid of $1.525m was offered, and that is where the auction pulled up and passed in. Sold after for an undisclosed price.

Kew: 6 Fenton Ave (Nick Whyte, Nelson Alexander), under hammer, $2.35m
6 Fenton Ave, Kew (Nick Whyte, Nelson Alexander), under hammer, $2.35m
A residential property with 726sqm of land in the heart of Kew? In this market, which has been very well supported for some time now and mainly bought by Chinese families, such a property should sell well, even though this is a cold winter’s day. But there is a catch. This home is an original one needing upgrade work and is deemed ‘contributory’ by local council, so effectively it cannot be knocked down. Given this, such properties traditionally have had limited appeal. ‘Would this be the case today?’ I pondered – along with about 80 others who had gathered to watch proceedings. Auctioneer Duncan McPherson energetically gave a quick spiel, and then paused for questions. An older man put up his hand and asked if the property was in a heritage overlay and if the house could be pulled down, which was no doubt a tactic to put other buyers off. Duncan responded promptly and professionally reiterating a lot of what he said in his preamble and after too much fuss, the auction was off and running. Opening with a bid of $1.9m, the auction took a bit to get going until Bidder 2 entered the fray, asking a few times if the property was on the market in the early $1.9ms. It wasn’t then, but was at $2.0m and two new Chinese parties started playing now for keeps and the property sold under the hammer for $2.35m. A strong result, but in this market not a totally crazy one. The landscape is changing though for what the Chinese are starting to buy, and it seems in this market that other than properties that defy good feng shui principles, then any property is good enough to buy.
Agent Opinion: How are stock levels looking now that the school holiday/winter hiatus is over?
Chris Hassall (Buxton, Bentleigh): “We have had a welcome break over the school holidays. The few auctions we have had have sold well. We have a healthy level of listings that will be auctioned in August so buyers should feel a little refreshed with stock levels.”
July 11, 2015
Due to school holidays, there is no Market Pulse this week.
July 4, 2015
Due to school holidays, there is no Market Pulse this week.
June 27, 2015

Albert Park: 374 Montague St (Hocking Holdsworth), after auction $1.16m
As we hit the halfway mark for the year, the Melbourne property mark continues to look healthy for sellers. Buyers are going to need to be on their ‘A’ game to ensure they buy the right home rather than any home.
Vendor expectations have started to creep up, in some cases above buyer expectations, particularly on properties with some concerns, no doubt hoping to capitalise on a good result because buyers are tired and frustrated and ready to buy anything – particularly without competition.
The winter months are traditionally a time of little activity, however, this has certainly not been the case this month, with many big sales taking place both at auction and off-market.
That being said, the next two weeks, (coinciding) with school holidays, will be quiet as most agents take time off to spend with family.
Talking over coffee with Michael Armstrong (Kay & Burton) during the week, he said he has had the busiest June ever which seems to be a general sentiment amongst agents.
There were fewer auctions on the weekend, many areas already quieting down for the holidays. Boroondara was the exception with a number of big auctions such at 126 Sackville Road Kew, 6a Raven Street Kew and 1A Monomeath Avenue Canterbury all selling over $3million.
Some highlights:
- 20 Studley Ave Kew (Belinda van Suylen/Jimmy Zang, Ray White Glen Waverley) sold strongly, quickly rising to $4.58m after selling just over $3m only 18 months earlier in January 2014. A fine home of great architectural merit by Sir Osborne McCutcheon, the layout largely in original condition with just a cosmetic update since the last sale.
- 60 Kooyong Road Armadale (Tim Picken, Kay & Burton) strong at $2.71m with 7 bidders fighting it out. A period home, yet a busy location and a few floor plan quirks. The big plus may have been the development potential, a pending multi-storey development to properties on the northern side only helping in terms of precedence. Such properties back in 2011 and 2012 were not at all favoured in the market – it’s a different story now.
- 35 Tourello Avenue Hawthorn East (Tim Heavyside, Fletchers). 920sqm, predominantly land, north rear sold before auction for $3.35m or $3641sqm. Although replacement of the home may be on the cards in the future, the home was an interesting one (originally a Victorian that had been renovated many times to adapt to a growing family’s needs), and the vendor’s thoughts on the information sheets made for great reading. This clearly was a happy family home.
One that faltered:
- 51 Service Street, Hampton (Lambros Bollos, Buxton) passed in on a vendor bid of $2.1m. 855sqm with approved plans for three townhouses. With early and strong interest in the campaign, the vendors opted to wait until auction, with no result on Saturday.
Off-markets:
- large modern home in Anderson Park area, Hawthorn East – circa $4m
- nicely renovated period home on good land in Camberwell’s Sunnyside Estate – $3.3-3.5m
- solid single-level period home in good condition in a signature Armadale street – $4m
- renovated three bedroom timber cottage, Hawthorn East – circa $1.6m
- elevated family home in Kew, north facing rear – $3.2-3.5m
- large 3 bed townhouse, Brighton Beach early $2millions
Looking ahead, buyers may take comfort knowing that the auctions for mid-late August look to be very healthy ones in terms of numbers with two of the Saturdays potentially offering over 1000 properties to buyers.
Architecturally Speaking: Townhouses

Bentleigh: Townhouse at 5b Somers Street Bentleigh (Peter Sinclair, Hodges) will go to auction this Saturday
A trend we are seeing in the market is the popularity of townhouses with buyers. This wasn’t really the case a few years back and it does seem that the dream of owning a property with a good-sized backyard to kick the footy around in is fading fast and the position along with a home that it easy to maintain is now an attractive option for families with busy lives.
Some things to look for:
- Good bedroom separation (ideally a main bedroom suite on the ground floor)
- Double car garaging
- Access to north light (being the ‘south side’ semi-attached dwelling really does affect the warmth and feel inside)
- Good amounts of storage
Auction Highlights:

Kew: 20 Studley Ave (Jeremy Tyrrell, Ray White), under hammer, $4.58m
20 Studley Ave, Kew (Jeremy Tyrrell, Ray White), under hammer, $4.58m
I was looking forward to this auction. It last sold early 2014 for just over $3m, and it is landmark local property with fine architectural merit. This would be good gauge of the Kew market, and with at least 7 properties selling in Kew area for around $2.5m and above in June alone.
Auctioneer Jeremy Tyrrell gave a concise, professional spiel in front of around 40 people on the elevated front garden, with the the towering McCutcheom designed home in the background.
Opening with a crowd bid of $3.18m by Bidder 1, Bidder 2 chimed in not long after and literally after about 2 minutes and about 10 bids the property sold for a whopping $4.58m!
The market in Kew is strong right now, and the strategy employed by the buyer (who was was not Asian looking in appearance) was a sound one – bid boldly and confidently, hitting a number with 8 in it each time.
Great result for the vendor, who did not make any major structural changes since they bought the home but was smart in the design of the cosmetic upgrade and the overall internal presentation.

Hampton: 51 Service St (Mark Earle, Buxton), passed in, $2.1m
51 Service St, Hampton (Mark Earle, Buxton), passed in $2.1m
Auctioneer, Mark Earle, started the auction by informing the crowd that around 100 contracts had been emailed to potential buyers. We were expecting some excitement!
After the usual slow start, Mark placed a vendor bid of $2m searching for a bidder to present. Eventually one did, offering $50,000, however, once it became apparent that there were not going to be any other bids forthcoming, Mark placed a second vendor bid of $2.1m and passed the property in.

Albert Park: 376 Montague St (Hocking Holsworth) passed in at $2m (VB), while next door’s unrenovated 374 sold after auction for $1.16m
376 & 374 Montague St, Albert Park (John Holdsworth/Shane Siemers, Hocking Holdsworth)
Number 376 went to auction first, a pretty Victorian that has been updated and extended with an architect designed renovation. John Holdsworth was MC in front of a big crowd of nearly 100 people, all keen to see what would happen at this double auction in Albert Park. Unable to secure any genuine bids from the crowd, John was forced to pass the property in on a vendor bid of $2m. Most of the spectators lingered to see what would transpire next door at 374, an un-renovated single-fronted Victorian currently offering three beds and one bathroom. A couple of bidders battled it out to the pass in price of $1.14m, before the property was sold after auction for $1.16m.
Agent Opinion: Do you have an predictions for Spring? With such a strong market in Boroondara, especially Kew, do you see an end in sight for the solid competition?
Peter Vigano (Jellis Craig): “As we are now in winter there are less and less properties coming onto the market, however buyer demand remains constant all year through. For any new properties that come onto the market in August in readiness for spring auctions, we expect to see pent up demand and prices continue to rise due to increasing demand due to the shortage of properties available. We are expecting a very busy spring selling season and we cannot foresee the market slowing down anytime soon.”
June 20, 2015

Brighton: 2 Munro St, (David Hart, Buxton), under hammer, $1.677m, 8 bidders
It appears we are going to leave the first half of the 2015 property market as we entered it in January – low stock levels and a large number of buyers still wanting to buy.
Although holidays are on the minds of many agents, there are still plenty of ‘off-market’ properties transacting quietly.
Late July and August is looking OK in terms of auctions/new properties on the market, yet we don’t think the supply will be enough to satisfy the depth of buyers.
Some highlights:
26 Wattle Valley Road, Canterbury (Dèsirèe Wakim / Hamish Tostevin) Passed in $3.6m, selling after well above this level. Corner blocks can sometimes be a tricky proposition for buyers, however, this was one that worked, offering a good feel inside and a classy renovation that has stood the test of time.
47 Erica Avenue, Glen Iris (Darren Krongold/Daniel Fisher, Gary Peer) sold for a very solid $3,650,000, having last sold only four years ago (2011) just under $2.4m. The interest and home formula that we have seen selling strongly in Balwyn over the last few years is now starting to take off in Stonnington.
1 Park Street, Brighton (Chris Carrington, Nick Johnstone Real Estate) 703sqm (approx) $3,575,000 having last sold in 2003 for $1.51m
Off-markets:
- Dated period home, good land, Kew – mid-to high $2ms
- 600sqm land, Toorak – mid $4ms
- Small brick cottage, Armadale – $1.2m
- Original home, renovate or rebuild, Highett $1m
- Period home, Armadale,- $4m
- 620sqm land, Balwyn High School zone $1.4-$1.5m
Land results:
33 Mont Victor Road Kew (Helen Yan / Jonathon Huntsman, Hocking Stuart) sold over $2.8m on the weekend. Only 14 months ago, April 2014, it sold for $1.87m. Wow! That is strong in any language, and it really does demonstrate the ‘heat’ in the Kew market right now. One million dollars in just over a year!
15 Fitzgerald Street Balwyn (Glen Coutinho / Heath Thompson, RT Edgar). 879sqm of good land with rear ROW with plans in place for two townhouses, just outside the Balwyn High School Zone. Sold strongly for $2,475,000, works out to be $2,815sqm.

Brighton East: 8 Vincent St (Buxton), passed in $1.55m, 2 bidders
There were a couple of quiet land sales transacted in Martin Street, Brighton this week (Stefan Whiting, Buxton).
- 1 Martin, 717sqm (approx), circa mid $4m after passing at auction in 2011 for $3,500,000
- 9 Martin, 1270sqm (approx.), in the higher $4millions after selling in 2013 in the mid $4millions,
Two inner city double storey properties sold on Saturday, both for $1,710,000. Comparing the two:
- 273 Richardson Street, Middle Park (David Lack, Biggin & Scott) had 4 bidders – an unrenovated Victorian, approximately 202sqm with ROW access (sold in 2006 $845,000 and 1992 $280,000
- 668 Rathdowne Street, Carlton North (Quentin Hinrichs, Woodards) had 3 bidders – fully renovated (although quite distinct in style, so some may wish to further update), approximately 196sqm with ROW access (last sold 1993 $166,000)
Auction Highlights:
Carlton North, 588 Rathdowne St, (Tom Roberts, Nelson Alexander), passed in $1.62m, 1 bidder
An unusual looking property this one, but it works for this part of inner Melbourne and with Rathdowne Village a short walk away, the offering is very appealing. Internally the home offered a lot of accommodation and was light and bright, yet tired in places. The big plus was the garage at the rear, which is very hard to find in this area. Auctioneer Tom Roberts (Nelson Alexander) gave a good preamble and dodges some passing traffic along the way, with listing agent James Keenan by his side. Opening with a vendor bid of $1.6m, the crowd of 30 or so looked at little disinterested and then a few minutes later a couple offered $1.62m and the property passed in to them. Sold after for $1,750,000, which was a good result for buyer and seller alike.

Carlton North: 588 Rathdowne St (Tom Roberts (Nelson Alexander), passed in $1.62m, 1 bidder
Middle Park, 273 Richardson St (David Lack, Biggin & Scott), under hammer, $1.71, 4 bidders
With dark clouds looming overhead and rain threatening the early morning auction, a small crowd gathered around auctioneer, David Lack. An opening bid of $1.4million started proceedings, and although the crowd was lacking in numbers, 4 bidders pushed past the reserve of $1.64m, where David announced that the property was selling. The hammer finally falling at $1.71m.

Middle Park: 273 Richardson St (David Lack, Biggin & Scott), under hammer, $1.71m, 4 bidders
Malvern East, 23 Finch Street (John Bongiorno, Marshall White), under hammer, $4.53m, 2 bidders
A large crowd gathered in the pretty front yard of this brick period home in the Gascoigne Estate, while children frolicked in the last remaining autumn leaves on the ground. John Bongiorno gave a thorough preamble and tabled a vendor bid of $4m straight out of the gate. Bidder 1 offered $4.12m and Bidder 2 came in shortly after. At $4.42m, Bidder 1 said he would bid again if the home was on the market. With that, Jack headed inside to speak with his vendor. Back outside, Jack announced the home was indeed on the market and Bidder 1 quipped “are you ready for that bid yet?” which brought some chuckles from the crowd. A battle between the two bidders ensued before the home sold to Bidder 1 for $4.53m.

Malvern East: 23 Finch St, (Jack Bongiorno), under hammer $4.53m, 2 bidders
Agent Opinion: Are buyers paying a premium price for land purchases that come with approved plans?
Kate Strickland (Marshall White): ‘Broadly purchasers will see plans in different levels of desirability based on their objective when buying the land. If there are plans for townhouses and they are wishing to build a family home then they are not going to add any value to the time, effort and dollars that have been outlayed to secure the plans and often permits. If the plans and permits are approved for what the prospective buyer is wanting to create, then they will definitely see the value and often push the price higher based on the ease and comfort of the process ahead. International buyers are falling into this category as they are wishing to begin demolition and build immediately at settlement.’
June 15, 2015

Hot auction! 39 Lambeth Ave, Armadale (Marshall White), under hammer, $4.66m, 4 bidders
At the risk of sounding like we are repeating ourselves, this weekend was another strong auction weekend in the $1m+ Melbourne property market. This trend should continue for good properties, attracting multiple bidders and strong prices before things quieten down for the June/July school holidays and the usual winter hiatus.
The Melbourne property market saw an almost 80% clearance rate for the nearly 800 homes auctioned.
Three years ago, in 2012, the same weekend had a clearance rate of only 55%, with just 550 homes to choose from.
The frustration for many buyers is continuing and this is now coupled with the downturn in stock.
For vendors wanting to sell their homes, around half prefer to sell first, ensuring they know exactly how much money they can spend on their next purchase. The other half prefer to buy first so they have something they can move straight into, avoiding the concerns of renting or multiple moves.
Whilst the market is strong, which should encourage vendors to sell, the lack of stock and continued increasing prices (which is starting to feel like a weekly phenomenon) does not provide the encouragement that their next home will be found easily and a period of time ‘out of the market’ may mean they can no longer afford what they thought they could.
Standout auction results this weekend included:
33 Hastings Road, Hawthorn East (Dave Oster/Scott Patterson, Kay & Burton). A basic builder-spec home, 780sqm approx., high side of street. $3.55m, 3 bidders – almost $1m more than it sold for back in 2011 at $2.4m.
39 Lambeth Avenue, Armadale (Justin Long/Mark Harris, Marshall White). A really well renovated home by renown architect Steve Domoney. Aside from the internal design and detailing which were very impressive, the dual car crossover and easy walk to High Street made this a winner on many fronts and received much interest from the ever emerging downsizer market. $4.66m and quarter of a million above the reserve price of $4.4m.
15 Rowell Avenue, Camberwell (Glen Coutinho/Nikki McCarthy, RT Edgar). A large land (just over 900sqm) in what is regarded by many as one of Camberwell’s best streets. Although the façade was a little understated, the layout was ideal for entertaining and the orientation captured the northern light. Sold under the hammer for $5.4m.
9 Margarita Street, Hampton (Nick Johnstone/Chris Carrington, Nick Johnstone Real Estate). An original timber home which had been renovated several times over it’s lifespan, and due for work again or perhaps knocking down to rebuild. The site itself was the key attraction; 777sqm, westerly rear, Hampton’s desired ‘Brighton Beach’ precinct. After an opening of $2.2m it sold for $2.45m with sizeable increments continuing after the reserve was met at around the $2.35m mark. Compare this result to the recent sale of 33 Margarita which was had a lesser house (admittedly) yet same rear orientation and very similar land size which was bought for $1.875m less than two months ago.
19 Freeman Street, Balwyn (Daniel Bradd/Walter Dodich, Marshall White). 714sqm in the Balwyn High School Zone. Offering good width at 16.75m and a north rear, it provided the formula for a strong auction, selling for just over $2.4m (or $3400/sqm).
Some of the better off-markets this week include:
- Renovated period home, Kew, 800sqm, north rear, early $3ms
- Modern single-level home, “Hill and Dale” Glen Iris, early $2ms
- Large family home, Armadale, $6m plus
- Single level home, smaller land, Armadale $3.5m plus
- Potential downsizer (main downstairs), low maintenance garden, Brighton early $4ms
Architecturally Speaking: Kitchen Design

A large kitchen bench top is both practical and often the place for family and friends to spend quality time
We were asked during the week how important the kitchen is within the home. Our response was simple: it is very important, perhaps the most important room, as it is the social ‘hub’ of the home. No longer regarded as ‘just a place to cook and prepare meals’. More than ever it is a conversation place for friends and family where quality time is spent. Can you overcapitalise? In the areas we buy for clients, we think it is hard to, but of course you need to be clever how you go about the design and material selection.
Trends:
- Clean, modern look, ability to conceal groceries and stand alone appliances easily (a butler’s pantry works well for this reason)
- Self-close drawers for just about everything, less cupboards
- Large island benches, mostly commonly with Caesarstone
- Integrated appliances (this should include refrigerators)
- Engineered timber flooring (hard wearing, looks good if installed property, and it can flow into other areas)
Auction Highlights:
33 Hastings Rd, Hawthorn East (Dave Oster, Kay & Burton), under hammer, $3.55m, 3 bidders
Selling for just over $2.4m back in 2011, this was always going to be an interesting auction.
Auctioneer Scott Patterson didn’t need to wait too long for a crowd bid – it came at $2.8m and pretty quickly the auction gathered pace. Bidder 1 didn’t look too strong and petered in the $3ms with bidders 2 and 3 fighting it out. Property was announced in the market at $3.3m and then sold strongly at $3.55m. Great result for listing agent Dave Oster, vendor should be very pleased!

Hawthorn East: 33 Hastings Rd (Dave Oster, Kay & Burton), under hammer, $3.55m, 3 bidders
9 Margarita St, Hampton (Nick Johnstone), under $2.45m, 2 bidders
The auction of the Californian bungalow on good sized land in coveted Margarita St, drew quite a good sized crowd when it went to auction on Saturday. Nick Johnstone gave a thorough preamble highlighting both the home and the location’s many assets before calling for an opening bid. Bidder 1 gave a strong $2.2m followed by $2.225m from Bidder 2 – both buyer advocates. Nick said there would be no half-time break and at $2.35m he announced that ‘by the way we are selling!’ Interestingly, there were a couple more sizeable bids after the home was announced on the market, before the hammer came down to Bidder 1 at $2.45m.

Hampton: 9 Margarita St (Nick Johnstone), under hammer, $2.45m, 2 bidders
28 Vickery St, Bentleigh (Craig Williamson, Buxton), under hammer, $2m, 3 bidders
Coffee machine, big crowd, big five bedroom family home in the McKinnon Secondary College zone – all signs pointed to a good auction at 28 Vickery St on Saturday. And we weren’t disappointed. Auctioneer Craig Williamson stepped out into the street and gave a thorough preamble before calling for an opening bid. Bidder 1, just to his left, gave a strong $1.74m and we were away. Bidder 2 was up for the challenge and entered the bidding at $1.76m. A couple more bids between the two ensued before we were hit with a ‘killer’ bid from Bidder 2 at $1.9m. Bidder 1 backed down but it was here that Bidder 3 entered the competition. At $1.96m Craig announced he would be selling. The price crept up slowly and methodically in a two-way battle before the hammer came down at $2m to a round of applause from the appreciative crowd.

Bentleigh: 28 Vickery St (Buxton), under hammer, $2m, 3 bidders
Agent Opinion: Are blocks of land that are selling with plans and permits getting a premium price?
Daniel Bradd (Kay & Burton): “Regardless of the state of the market, properties offered with plans and permits do attract premium prices as they negate the time delays and holding costs associated with the planning process provided that what is approved is actually feasible from both a resale and construction cost prospective. In the current market however, those properties offering redevelopment potential, particularly in council’s new ‘Growth Zones’ or areas unencumbered by heritage controls, whether for single home or multiple dwellings, are attracting premium prices without permits as opportune buyers attempt to capitalise on the increased demand for new properties across all price points.”
June 9, 2015

Camberwell: 9 Bringa Ave (Peter Vigano, Jellis Craig), under hammer, $3.316m
A shortened Market Pulse from us this week as there were only a very few auctions due to the Queen’s Birthday weekend. Numbers at opens were down and expectedly so given many people were away. That said, there are some good properties up for sale right now.
A feature auction of the weekend was 9 Bringa Avenue Camberwell:
Opening with a vendor bid of $2.7m, auctioneer Peter Vigano (Jellis Craig) gave a no-nonsense preamble for this auction, where a solid crowd of around 100 turned up to see what would transpire. Not long after the start, bidders 1 and 2 went into battle and the property was announced on the market at just over the $3m mark. Enter Bidder 3 shortly after and the heat picked up. Sitting down and a bit deflated, our original bidder looked gone and the auction went up a level, with Bidder 2 winning the day at $3.316m. This was a telling result and a good indication of the market right now, as we remember next door (no.11) selling strongly last year for $2.56m. That had a similar land size yet a slightly lesser home.

Camberwell: 9 Bringa Ave, (Peter Vigano, Jellis Craig)
‘Off market’ properties are alive and well right now. A few of the better ones we have been through this week include:
- Well-built modern architect-designed home in Hawthorn – circle $4m
- Solid, English style family home in Toorak – north facing rear – circle $4m
- Well presented two-storey Victorian ROW terrace, short walk to Lygon Street and Melbourne Uni – circle $1.5m
- Single storey home, walk to shops, Brighton, mid $2’s
Good properties we visited this week that should attract solid competition:
- 35 Tourello Avenue, Hawthorn East (Tim Heavyside, Fletchers). A great block of land – it really doesn’t get much better in this area. 920sqm, north facing rear and over 20m frontage.
- 26 Wattle Valley Road Canterbury (Desiree Wakim, Marshall White). Well renovated and extended period family home, good-sized corner block, walk to Maling Road. With a shortage of good family homes this should be competitive. Although the kitchen was perhaps a tad small the rear open plan area worked really well and had a nice feel, with good balance of formal and informal spaces.
- 2 Munro Street Brighton (David Hart, Buxton). Basic double-fronted timber Victorian, liveable now with options to improve. This property has great opportunity to extend and renovate. Creating off-street parking at the back via the side laneway may also be possible. Another potential for downsizers prepared to do a little work, given proximity to Church St shops.

Canterbury: 26 Wattle Valley Road, high ceilings and good window placement bring in plenty of sunlight
Architecturally Speaking:
Many people who have recently bought are taking the next step and commencing renovations earlier than originally planned. With money currently affordable, the increased property prices have provided the additional equity to start works early.
If you like where you live, the option to renovate (if done well and cleverly) may be a great solution, as the price jump to the next property is becoming prohibitive for many.
As always, it is really important to buy a home with excellent flexibility as it provides the opportunity to do this this and it gives you options – for example it could be better for young singles/couples to buy a 600sqm unrenovated, smaller home, that can easily be upgraded, than a glitzy, modern-finished townhouse with small land content and no option to extend or improve.
The value of a good architect as always is hard to quantity in dollar terms.
![FullSizeRender[10]](https://www.woledgehatt.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/FullSizeRender101.jpg)
Renovations underway in Beaumaris
May 30, 2015
![FullSizeRender[1]](https://www.woledgehatt.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/FullSizeRender1.jpg)
Hampton: 11 Avondale St (James Paynter, RT Edgar), passed in $3.050m
Some highlights:
- 3 Miller Street, Brighton (James Paynter/Greg Costello, RT Edgar) – 6 bidders $8.04m or $11,770/sqm (approx.) for beachfront golden mile.
- 16 Missouri Avenue, Brighton (Kate Strickland, Marshall White), good volume brick Bungalow home, yet south-facing with no garage – 5 bidders, $2.21m.
- 21 Iona Street, Black Rock (Jenny Dwyer, Hocking Stuart), single-level timber period home, north rear, 3 bedrooms – 5 bidders $1.765m.
- 16 Stawell Street, Kew (Hamish Tostevin/Desiree Wakim, Marshall White), prime Studley Park position with great presence and solid formal rooms; however, compromised back yard size due to corner block and position of building, plus a heritage overlay protecting the building – 4 bidders, passing in at $3.3m and selling after $3.35m.
- 13 Fermanagh Road, Camberwell (Stuart Robinson, Jellis Craig) a slightly updated version of the model that sold in November 2013 for just over $3m, sold this week as a private sale for an undisclosed amount, the vendors profiting around $750,000 only 18 months on.
Pass-ins:
- 11 Avondale Street, Hampton (James Paynter, RT Edgar), approximately two-year-old ‘period home’ with desired family floorplan in one of Hampton’s premier locations – surprisingly only 1 bidder was prepared to show their hand among the crowd of around 120, offering $3.05m. This may be one where the hype of the market has scared buyers off, worried that they weren’t ‘in with a chance’, as we found it hard to fault the property. ‘A’ grade Hampton, walk to beach, shops, station and schools with a flexible family floorplan and a double garage.
- 56 Ardoyne Street, Black Rock (Romana Altman, Buxton) passed in on a vendor bid of $2.6m. This property last sold competitively at auction only a couple of years ago for $2.575m but this weekend there was no interest at this level.

Black Rock: 56 Ardoyne St (Mark Earle, Buxton), passed in, $2.6m
Land was contested heavily again:
- 3 Miller Street, Brighton (mentioned above) $8.01m, 683sqm – $11,770sqm.
- 40 Balmerino Avenue, Toorak over $4.8m, 700 sqm – getting closer to $7000sqm.
- 40 Parslow Street, Malvern over $2.2m, 650sqm – around $3400sqm.
- 12 Harts Parade, Hawthorn East $2.04m, 601sqm –$3,394sqm.
Off market properties have continued to increase in number this week.
Some new options to consider include:
- Hampton – north-facing land, approximately 675sqm, high $1m.
- Hampton – single-storey renovated home with garaging, circa $2m.
- Brighton – large land holding with renovated home, pool and court, circa $10m.
- Brighton – entry level renovated home, close to amenities, high $1m.
- Malvern – corner site period home, suit downsizer, with garaging, early $3m.
- Camberwell – good land buy, north rear, middle Camberwell, high $2m.
- Glen Iris – modern home with pool, circa $3m.
- Toorak – single-storey home, 4 bed, north rear, quiet location, early $3m.
Next weekend is the Queen’s Birthday holiday weekend. The property market shuts down while focus is diverted to the opening of the ski season. Have a great long weekend and we will be back in a couple of weeks.
Auction Highlights:

Kew, 16 Stawell St (Antony Woodley, Marshall White), after auction, 4 bidders
16 Stawell St, Kew (Antony Woodley, Marshall White), after auction, $3.35m, 4 bidders
A good crowd of around 80 gathered for the early morning auction of 16 Stawell Street. Auctioneer, Antony Woodley, gave his usual polished performance. A genuine bid opened the day for $2,700,000 with a second bidder joining in immediately. The first bidder was quick to stop with a third taking their place, steady increments quickly taking the price over $3m. It became clear after Bidder 4 asked if it was ‘on the market’ that this was an auction where bidders were competing for the first right to negotiate with the vendor. Bidder 4 eventually achieving that right at $3.3m. The final result $3.35m.
![IMG_0281[1]](https://www.woledgehatt.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/IMG_02811.jpg)
Brighton: 16 Missouri Ave (Peter Kakos, Marshall White), under hammer, $2.21m, 5 bidders
Around 65 people gathered in the front yard and on the footpath outside the property, keen to see what would transpire at auction on Saturday. Peter Kakos was our master of ceremonies and after a thorough preamble, called for an opening bid. Bidder 1 offered $1.75m and we were away. Two bidders took the price to $1.9m at which point Kate Strickland dashed inside to seek instructions from her vendor. Once outside again, Kate gave Peter a smile and a nod and Peter declared that at $1.95m, yes we were selling. By now, Bidder 3 had entered the fray and shortly after Bidder 4 threw his hat into the ring. Bidder 5 chimed in for a while, but it was Bidder 4 who stayed strong throughout, outbidding all the others to become the happy new owner at $2.210m. A great auction.
![IMG_0217[3]](https://www.woledgehatt.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/IMG_02173.jpg)
Black Rock: 21 Iona St (Peter Kennett, Hocking Stuart), under hammer, $1.765m 5 bidders
This beautifully presented home attracted a lot of interest when it went to auction on Saturday. Around 100 people traipsed through the home prior to proceedings to get a glimpse of the house that had featured in a national home magazine, styled by its interior designer owner. Peter Kennett debated whether to hold the auction in the street or the picture perfect backyard, but decided on the latter, which was a great choice as the huge crowd fit comfortably in the impeccably manicured gardens. “It’s autumn time, it’s auction time and it’s action time,” Peter boomed, and after an extremely entertaining spiel, he called for ann opening bid. A strong offer of $1.4m came from the rear of the crowd. Bidder 2 was quick to reply at $1.425m and a short battle between the two ensued before bidders three and four entered the competition. Jenny Dwyer headed inside to seek instructions from her vendor and once back out, at $1.65m, Peter declared he was selling. Bidder 5 entered the competition and after a great battle, at $1.765m Bidder 1 declared Bidder 5 “can have it,” thus ending a great competition and very entertaining auction.
Agent Opinion: Advice for buyers at auctions over winter

John Clarkson (Hocking Stuart): “Buyers, do your homework, attend auctions to watch a variety of styles and don’t be afraid to ask auctioneer if it is on the market!”
May 23, 2015

Brighton: 25 Lynch St (Hodges), under hammer $1.92m, 2 bidders
With nearly 1000 auctions on the weekend the results for good family homes, good land buys and those appealing to the downsizer market, were good all round.
Some highlights –
46 Canberra Grove Brighton East (Peter Kennett, Hocking Stuart). 800sqm, newer build family home, $4.01m. Only a few years ago, sales in Brighton East over $2m were scarce, they are now commonplace.
Three reasons:
- Increased prices in Brighton – pushing buyers out to fringe areas
- The increased popularity and strength of St Leonards and Haileybury Grammar schools
- Practical family floorplans. Many of the older homes have now been rebuilt and starting to present for sale
3 Ridgeway Avenue Kew (Doug McLauchlan, Marshall White). Neat brick Edwardian home, a short walk from Kew Junction sold for a tick over $2.6m.
- A house next door (similar land, slightly lesser condition house) selling for $1.7m back in November 2012. This is a good indication of how much the market has moved in about 30 months.
32 Flowerdale Road Glen Iris (Bryan Cain, First National). Modern single level home, quality street. Bought undisclosed, a little over $2.5m.
Land was contested heavily again:
16 Waterloo Street Camberwell (Tom Ryan/Geordie Dixon, Jellis Craig) 415m2 with approved permits for a two-storey home bought just shy of $1.8m, around $4,500sqm.
31 Glen Street Hawthorn (Chloe Quinn/Richard Earle, Jellis Craig). 487sqm bought just north of $1.8m, around $,3700sqm.
1 Mildura Avenue Sandringham (Nic Tanner, JP Dixon) 460sqm corner block, good location to shops, transport and beach (abutting private tennis courts) bought for $1,405,000 or $3,054sqm.
As we approach winter and the upcoming school holidays, off-markets properties (i.e. those not publicly advertised) are alive and well.
Some examples:
- Updated single level timber home in Hampton – circa $1.7-1.8m
- Double-storey renovated Victorian Row Terrace in South Melbourne – circa $2.5m
- Solid period family home in Studley Park Kew – circa $2.5m
- Renovated period home, north rear, good off-street parking, Armadale $3.5-4m
- Renovator’s delight, Malvern East, 800sqm, north rear, circa $2.5m
As stock levels start to slow down for winter, buyers may wish to consider whether they want to wait until spring before they buy their new home.
There will be buyers willing to sell quietly during this time, particularly if they have already purchased.
Now is the time to work out how you can best access the properties available for transaction quietly.
We have found the best way is ‘coffee’ catch ups with key agents to find the properties and then the appropriate supporting data to help buyers understand ‘values’ when there is no opportunity for ‘social proof’ (such as other buyers inspecting the home, or bidding at auction) around pricing.
Architecturally Speaking
Island benches
This is high on the wish list of most of most clients we talk to (buying and designing homes), and the homes that tend to sell well often have a great kitchen. The ‘Island bench’ is really important, as it is often the central “communication and social hub” of the home and it helps with the functionality of the working kitchen. Main points to consider:
- Size (should be at least 2.1m x 1m in size
- Needs easy access to power, perhaps power point to the side as minimum
- Depending on size best not to have the kitchen sink as part of it (particularly if smaller)
- Should feature draws on the working side, for easy access to all storage
There was a great island bench in the home we visited this week at 15 Rowell Avenue Camberwell (Nikki McCartky/Glen Coutinho, RT REdgar). (see pic below)
Large, facing north facing windows and acting in part as informal dining area, this works really well and you are really drawn to it’s presence.

Auction Highlights:
1 Russell Street, Toorak (Rob Vickers-Willis, Abercromby’s), under hammer, $3.96m, 5-6 bidders
Pretty as a picture, this well-built brick original home in a quiet Toorak location saw a good crowd gathering for it’s auction. Auctioneer Rob Vickers-Willis and listing agent Jeff Gole conducted proceedings in the private backyard, and around 40 were in attendance. Opening with a genuine offer of $3.1m, the auction clipped along nicely with a string of bids and before too long with at least four bidders pushed the action along to $3.325m, when the property was announced “on the market”. No half-time break was needed, with Rob and Jeff taking bids very quickly and in the end it was a battle of two Chinese families that really upped the ante over the $3.7mark, with one of them winning the day (and the property) at $3.96m. Land was the really key to the success of this property; just over 600m2 and a corner block with no heritage overlay works out to be just under $6,600/m2 – very healthy indeed.

Toorak: 1 Russell St (Abercromby’s), under hammer, $3.96 m, 5-6 bidders
34 Marchant St, Highett (Adam Gillon, Buxton), under hammer $1.435m, 3 bidders
The crowd started gathering long before Adam Gillon took centre stage. First it looked like around 70 people had come to watch the auction but that number quickly grew to 100 and then 150 in the minutes prior to the start of proceedings. The coffee van was a huge hit too and the line only dispersed as Adam started his preliminaries. Calling for an opening bid, a baby wailed: “Don’t cry,” Adam soothed. “Mum and dad still have a chance to buy it!” Bidder 1 offered $1.1m and we were away. Bidder 2 gave a strong $1.2m and before long, Bidder 3 was in at $1.35m. There was a slight pause and, as if on cue, an elderly cyclist broke the silence, announcing his arrival with the loud ringing of his bell. And as he sped through the middle of the crowd, he gave Adam a high five much to the amusement of the spectators. At $1.41m the home was on the market. More laughs as a metre reader entered the property for sale, “life goes on,” laughed agent Paul Sibley. And with a couple more bids, the home was sold to a young family, the hammer coming down to a massive round of applause at $1.435m.

Highett: 34 Marchant St (Buxton), under hammer $1.435m, 3 bidders
17 Willansby St, Brighton (David Hart, Buxton), under hammer, $1.67m, 10 bidders
With 17 Willansby Street selling last week with 5 bidders for $1,230,000, there was much anticipation around 6 Willansby which offered approximately 200sqm more land and a larger, original cream brick home.
Starting with a fairly low initial bid of $1,100,000, auctioneer David Hart quickly placed a vendor bid of an extra $100,000, and moments later a second bidder entered the competition with another rise of $100,000 to $1,300,000. From here, the bids continued in quick succession – 10 bidders in total – and a final price of $1,670,000.

Brighton: 17 Willansby St, (Buxton), under hammer, $1.67m, 10 bidders
Agent Opinion: Tips for selling and buying in the winter months
David Gillham (Noel Jones, Camberwell): “Winter is statistically the best time to sell,of course avoiding the June /July school holidays when buyers tend to chase the warmer climates in North Queensland and onto farther destinations.We find the lack of good property around seems to pump the prices of any property placed on the market at this time, simply the supply and demand imbalance comes to the fore. Don’t be frightened of the weather, buyers will bid in the snow if they love a property enough,it is the economic climate that prevails and we all know how strong that is at the moment.”